Smart choices reduce the climate impact of your IT use

The effects of the climate crisis are here. Weather and climate extremes affect every region across the globe, with flooding, drought and damage to nature and people. We must act now to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from all significant sources, including IT products.

Global warming is now 1.1°C above pre-industrial levels. To limit warming to 1.5 or even 2 degrees, emissions must be cut in half by 2030, compared with 2019. Instead, the levels of greenhouse gases in our atmosphere continue to rise. Emissions stem from a variety of sources, and IT products are no exception.

Computers, phones and other IT products are a source of greenhouse gases throughout their life cycle — from manufacturing to distribution, use and disposal. For most IT products, a majority of these emissions occur in the manufacturing phase. The manufacturing process is energy-intensive, and a majority of factories are powered by fossil fuels. Greenhouse gases are also emitted during transportation and use of the IT product, but in comparison to the manufacturing phase, the impacts are relatively small. Therefore, energy-saving features and switching to a more energy-efficient product have marginal effects. The most important thing is to use products longer.

Climate change, circularity and e-waste are closely linked

Improving the life cycle management of IT is a powerful way to reduce the climate impact. Today, we often give these products a short life. Once they are discarded, only a small percentage is recycled. Instead, virgin natural resources are used to produce new products, which leads to larger greenhouse gas emissions than if recycled materials were used.

In our mostly linear economy, we are overusing finite natural resources, and in our pursuit of them, natural habitats with vegetation which can capture carbon are being destroyed. The short life we give IT products also creates huge amounts of toxic e-waste – more than 50 million metric tons, a figure that grows every year. In many ways, climate change, circularity and e-waste are closely linked. Addressing one of these areas will have a positive impact on the other two.

Most emissions are scope 3

A majority of total life cycle emissions from an IT product are scope 3. These are emissions that occur in an organization’s value chain. Scope 3 includes emissions from the manufacturing process of the IT product, including material sourcing, material refinery, component manufacturing, final assembly and transportation to the user. Downstream emissions from e-waste management and recycling are also included.

The exact figure for scope 3 is difficult to know, partly because it varies between product categories, and partly because the IT sector is constantly evolving. But the primary challenge is to get hold of reliable data from the IT product supply chain, which is complex and geographically widespread. Measuring the climate impact of a single product model requires collecting data from a large number of suppliers and sub-suppliers, many of which remain unknown. Data is mostly unverified, so the accuracy level is uncertain and the risk of greenwashing is high.

There is great uncertainty in the calculation of product carbon footprints

There is a wide range of systems and services that offer carbon footprint calculations. Each is designed differently and based on different methods and assumptions. This lack of standardization means that you get very different results depending on which system you use, which makes comparisons difficult and inaccurate.

It is also sometimes unclear what should be included in the climate footprint. For example, should only the production line for a specific product model be taken into consideration, or the entire factory? What about the emissions from transportation between the factory and the workers’ homes, which would not have been needed if manufacturing did not occur? Another challenge is synchronizing data between organizations, for example between the brand owner which designs and produces the product, and the organization which buys and uses it. There is a risk that the same emissions are counted twice, or on the contrary, that they are not reported by anyone.

What scope 1, 2 and 3 means for IT products

Scope 1

Direct emissions that stem from vehicles, equipment or other devices owned or controlled by an organization, for example, from diesel cars used by employees. For a purchasing organization measuring emissions from IT hardware: No scope 1 emissions.

Scope 2

Owned, indirect emissions from generating the electricity purchased and used by an organization, for example, to heat or cool the office building. For a purchasing organization measuring emissions from IT hardware: Emissions from the energy required to charge and run the notebook computer.

Scope 3

Not owned, indirect emissions that occur in an organization’s value chain. For a purchasing organization measuring emissions from IT hardware: emissions from the manufacturing process of the IT product, including material sourcing, material refinery, component manufacturing, final assembly, and transportation to the user. Downstream emissions from e-waste management and recycling are also included.

Progress is more important than perfection

Whilst the difficulties in measuring greenhouse gas emissions and carbon footprints have become increasingly clear, regulatory and stakeholder demands on organizations to measure and report these figures are increasing. However, measuring does not automatically lead to reduced emissions. With a climate emergency on our doorstep, there is an urgency to make real reductions. This work cannot wait until we have perfect measurement tools. “What you don’t measure, you can’t manage” has become a universal truth, but maybe this phrase should be questioned. Even if not all numbers are in place, we already know enough to take action.

Six actions for reducing your climate impact

Here are some ways your organization can act now to reduce your emissions in the IT life cycle.

1
The most important thing you can do to lower your carbon footprint is to use products for a longer time.

2
When you purchase a product, select one with good enough performance to cover your needs for a few years, at least.

3
Make sure that the product you buy is durable and possible to repair and upgrade.

4
Set up a scheme for redeploying IT products internally. After its first use, a product may work just fine in a less data-intensive function.

5
Remember that your IT products could have value even if they no longer meet the needs of your organization. Give it a second life by selling or donating it.

6
Once the product has reached the end of its usable life, ensure it is recycled safely and responsibly.

How using TCO Certified helps you lower emissions

To help reduce the climate impact of IT products, criteria in TCO Certified are designed to drive the development of products that can live longer. Criteria for energy efficiency are also included, for both products and factories. When you cite TCO Certified in your procurement specifications, the certified products you receive are designed to help lower your footprint.

Product lifetime extension
  • Criteria cover all phases of the product life cycle: material sourcing and manufacturing; use and reuse; recovery and recycling.
  • IT products are often replaced because the battery has lost its ability to hold a charge. TCO Certified includes criteria for battery life and replaceability.

  • The brand owner must provide software that deletes data from the device securely and free of charge so that the product can be recirculated without risk of data leakage.

  • Certified products must have at least one year’s warranty, and spare parts must be available throughout the certificate’s validity period.

  • To promote the circular economy, products must be repairable and upgradeable to remain functional for a long time.
  • By reducing the number of hazardous substances, materials can be safely recycled and reused for a long time and stay compliant with increasingly stricter legislation.
  • Computers and mobile products must include a USB Type-C port. By using a standardized connector for data and charging, fewer cables need to be manufactured, and the reuse of cables can increase.
  • Mobile products must be durable and endure high and low temperatures.
Energy efficiency
  • To reduce energy consumption, certified products must be energy efficient and meet the requirements of Energy Star® or equivalent.
  • To drive improvements in factories where certified products are manufactured, energy efficiency in manufacturing must be reported annually.
  • Final assembly factories must be certified to ISO 50001, demonstrating a systematic approach to energy efficiency and a commitment to improving their energy performance.

TCO Certified is the world’s most comprehensive sustainability certification for IT products, helping you make responsible product choices that drive the industry in a sustainable direction. Using TCO Certified also supports your organization in taking the next step in social and environmental responsibility.

You might be interested in:

Social challenges in the IT product supply chain

Conflict minerals used in IT products drive wars and human rights abuses

Hazardous substances in IT products — and how to avoid them

A growing, toxic waste stream where valuable finite resources are lost

Circularity helps you tackle many of today’s sustainability risks

Smart choices reduce the climate impact of your IT use

Sources of information
  • AR6 Synthesis Report, Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), 2023
  • European Commission Joint Research Centre (2009). Environmental Impact of Products (EIPRO): Analysis of the Life Cycle Environmental Impacts Related to the Final Consumption of the EU-25. This study provides a comprehensive analysis of the environmental impact of various products, including laptops, and estimates that manufacturing contributes to about 70% of the total lifecycle GHG emissions for laptops.
  • Prakash, S., Dehoust, G., Gsell, M., Schleicher, T., & Stobbe, L. (2010). Einfluss der Nutzungsdauer von Produkten auf ihre Umweltwirkung: Schaffung einer Informationsgrundlage und Entwicklung von Strategien gegen „Obsoleszenz“. Umweltbundesamt. This study also supports the finding that the manufacturing phase of laptops contributes significantly to their overall lifecycle GHG emissions.
  • Wäger, P. A., Hischier, R., & Eugster, M. (2011). Environmental impacts of the Swiss collection and recovery systems for Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE): a follow-up. The Science of the Total Environment, 409(10), 1746-1756. This study analyzes the environmental impacts of WEEE collection and recovery systems, including the manufacturing phase’s contribution to the lifecycle emissions of laptops.
  • International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications – Green IT: Energy Efficient Computer Manufacturing (2013)
  • The Global E-waste Monitor 2020: A collaborative report published by the United Nations University (UNU), International Telecommunication Union (ITU), and International Solid Waste Association (ISWA) to provide an overview of the e-waste problem and its management.
  • Eurostat: The statistical office of the European Union provides data on e-waste recycling rates in EU countries.
  • United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA): The EPA publishes information on e-waste management, including recycling rates in the United States.